You are currently viewing Understanding Crested Succulents & Monstrose Cactus

Understanding Crested Succulents & Monstrose Cactus

Among the many (many) reasons we succulent lovers are fascinated by these plants is the extraordinary richness and diversity of forms and textures they display. We often come to prize the more unusual varieties. Nowhere, will you find more strange, unusual and incredibly cool forms than among crested succulents and monstrose cactus. Like most variegated succulents, both cristata succulents and “monster cactus” are the result of abnormal development of the plant. This is a naturally occurring phenomenon that is tricky to reproduce. Cresting causes wildly curved, twisted and undulating plants that look very different from un-crested forms. Crested cactus often look like writhing snakes, coral or even human brains. Maybe you’re intrigued by these curiosities. Or maybe you have a plant displaying strange growth and want to understand it. Learn why some succulents and cactus crest and how to care for them.

Crested Succulents & Monster Cactus

What are Crested Succulents and Cactus?

Echeveria ‘Cubic Frost™’ PPAF
photo credit Leaf Clay

To understand crested succulents and cactus, let’s first look at how normal plants grow and develop. We’ve covered the nature of meristem tissue when we looked at propagating succulents by leaves as well as stem cuttings. Meristem tissue is made up of immature cells that can develop to become anything the plant needs – stem, root or leaf. Its like stem cells in animals.

The meristem tissue at the very tips of roots and shoots is called apical meristem. It forms a small point at the apex that is responsible for the plant’s primary growth. Apical meristem tissue makes the plant grow taller, developing more leaves for photosynthesis. At the same time, apical meristem on the roots grow longer, wider-spreading roots to reach and access more water in the soil. These are critical functions for the plant. While all meristem tissue is capable of growth in the right circumstances, apical meristem tissue does grow and is responsible for the plant’s shape and size.

Saguaro cactus Carnegiea gigantea, cresting
photo credit NPS

A crested cactus or succulent is the result of a genetic defect in the apical meristem. The apical meristem tissue of a normal saguaro cactus cause the classic vertical, columnar shapes. Occasionally the cactus branches, but most of its growth continues to reach for the sky. When a saguaro crests, the apical meristem no longer forms a single point. Instead, it forms a broad line, with new growth points forming all along that line. The resulting plant shape becomes wildly distorted and contorted along that line. As the plant grows taller and wider along the resulting crest, the plant begins to curl and fold in upon itself. A crested succulent or cactus has the Latin word cristata added to its botanical name. So we call a saguaro (Carnegiea gigantea) that crests a Carnegiea gigantea cristata.

What is a Monstrose Cactus or Succulent?

Monstrose form euphorbia
Euphorbia Monstrose, photo credit Leaf and Clay

Monstrose is another form of a genetic defect in the apical meristem of a plant. The organized points of new growth become random, forming all over the body of the plant, causing new growth to form anywhere. A crested cactus or succulent still displays organized growth with a predisposition toward symmetrical development. A monstrose cactus, however, develops in random growth points all over the plant. This results in a lumpy, knobby, asymmetrical shape. Sometimes monstrose cactus develop bizarre corkscrew spirals or extra ribs with very few or deformed spines. Like crested succulents, monstrose cactus are highly sought after and collectible plants.

Monstrose cactus are often referred to as monster cactus. The two words share the same root word — monstrum, meaning birth defect with abnormal, disfigured growth. While animals with weird deformities might appear to us as monsters, in plants, the same genetic mix-ups often turn out looking bizarrely cool.

What Causes Cresting and Monstrose Development in Succulents?
crested succulent Mamillaria elongata ‘Copper King’ cristata

Although both cresting and monstrose forms are the result of genetic defects, they cannot be inherited. Generally, a crested or monstrose plant is the result of an injury to the apical meristem of a young plant. This injury might be the result of wind, weather, insects, bird or animals. Sometimes a nutritional deficiency or hormone imbalance can lead to cresting or monstrose. It can result from disease or infections, or even seem to occur spontaneously when cells divide improperly. When the cells respond to the injury with fast, somewhat organized growth, it forms a crest. When the new growth occurs all over the plant, that is a monstrose. Any type of plant can develop a crest or monstrose, but they do seem more common with cactus and succulents. Likely, the tough nature of these plants makes them better able to survive to maturity even with genetic defects than other plants.

Because cresting and monstrose formations result from injury to the plant, the abnormal growth is not typically passed on to the plant’s offspring. An injured parent doesn’t develop an injured offset. However, some cactus and euphorbia varieties are more likely to crest than others. And this predisposition is hereditary. You may see both crested and normal development on the same plant. You may even see all three forms, with monstrose growth in the mix. A plant may crest at any point in its life, but monstrose typically develop only in very young plants.

Crassula ovata 'ET's Fingers' Jade - Variegata
Crassula ovata ‘ET’s Fingers’ Jade – Variegata
photo credit Mountain Crest Gardens

There are a very few varieties that do reliably pass their peculiarities on to their offspring and can be readily reproduced through cuttings. Notable among these are the Crassula ovata Hobbit, Gollum and ET’s Fingers varieties of the ever-popular jade plant. Not only do these charming plants resemble the outstretched fingers of some inhabitants of Middle Earth, but these succulents also thrive in low light, indoor conditions.

Care for Crested and Monstrose Succulents
potted succulent euphorbia lactea cristata

Every crested and monstrose succulent develops into a fantastical form unique to the individual plant. Plants evolve their growth rates, shape and sizes over millions of years to enable them to thrive in their native habitat. So it’s no surprise that these one-of-a-kind plants are a bit more sensitive to environmental pressures than their un-crested counterparts. Crested and monstrose cactus and succulents are actually quite stable and able to grow for years with care. They tend to be even more sensitive to over-watering and fertilizing than un-crested plants of the same species. The abnormal tissues are more prone to splitting, rotting or additional injury. Provide the same lighting and temperature controls you would for that succulent variety, just give the crested form even less water, less often and with less fertilizer. This is known as growing the plant “harder”.

Propagating and Pruning Crested and Monstrose Cactus
crested euphorbia grafted to a cactus rootstock
Grafted, crested cactus
photo credit Bill Gracey | (CC BY-NC-ND 2.0)

Because crested and monstrose succulents are the result of injury and not heredity, the fabulous forms are not passed down to the plant’s offspring. You cannot get more crested succulents through collecting and sowing seeds from the plant. Instead, crested succulents are propagated from cuttings taken from a part of the plant that is cresting. These cuttings are generally grafted to a hardy cactus rootstock, the way moon cactus are. Grafting helps to make the plant more stable, as the root structure is provided by a vigorous, un-injured plant.

In time, you may see a normal succulent develop a crest. Sometimes a crested or monstrose cactus develops normal growth. It may sprout from the rootstock or the plant may revert to normal growth patterns. If you want to maintain the crested form, cut back any shoots of normal plant growth. In time, normal growth can out-compete the crested growth and cause the entire plant to revert.

Buying Crested Succulents and Monstrose Cactus
Opuntia hybrid Cristata 'Roller Coaster'
Opuntia Hybrid Cristata Roller Coaster
photo credit Leaf and Clay

Many succulent lovers go wild for the bizarre forms of crested and monstrose succulents. Although they are rare, you can find good quality crested succulents pretty easily. Sometimes, even at big box stores. My favorite succulent vendors are great sources for these spectacular plants. Leaf & Clay offers an intriguing array of 16 different named monstrose and crested succulents. For some, like Echeveria ‘Cubic Frost™’, they carry both the normal and crested varieties. Mountain Crest Gardens offers a few crested succulents as well as a few monstrose varieties. The Succulent Source has an ever-changing selection of crested and monstrose succulents and cactus. Some of their selection, especially the larger specimens, allow you to choose the exact crested or monstrose plant you want.

You’ll also find crested and monstrose succulents on Amazon and here on Etsy. Wherever you get your plant, I hope you’ll give one of these phantasmagorical beauties a try!

I hope you’ve enjoyed this walk on the wild side. Do you already grow crested succulents, or do you plan to give one of these phantasmagorical beauties a try? I’d love to hear from you! Please take a moment to leave me a comment and let me know. Especially if you have any questions!

’til next time,

P.S. For more succulent info — and to just make my day! — please subscribe to The Succulent Eclectic! I’ll send you my FREE course, 7 Steps to Succulent Success. Thanks!

Learn all about crested succulents and monstrose cactus
Black Aeonium shown both growing and dormant
(Visited 17,096 times, 8 visits today)

This Post Has 14 Comments

  1. Diane

    I love your article on crested succulents & monstrose cactus-so very informative! I live in a small town and have only seen a crested succulent once. By the time I decided to buy, it was gone. That was months ago. Still waiting for more to come along. I so appreciate your articles. I have learned a lot. Thanks for all your help and information. Diane.

    1. Kat McCarthy

      Hi Diane,
      You are most welcome! 🙂
      These are such fascinating plants! When you manage to snag one, you’ll keep it happy for years if you are extra stingy with the water.
      Thanks so much for your comment!

  2. Lee Richardson-Greenan

    Hi Kat, what’s the secret to making succulents more colorful? I ❣your articles they’re exactly what I need to know. Lee

    1. Kat McCarthy

      Hi Lee – Great question! 🙂
      The Secret to More Colorful Succulents – is stress!
      Read all about how stress – and what kind! – makes succulents more colorful. But also pay attention to which succulents will get more colorful.
      Once you finish that post, I did another telling you exactly how to stress your succulents for more color.
      Thanks SO much for reading!

  3. Lazy K

    I have a crested Eves Needle (Austrocylindropuntia subulata ‘Cristata).
    I accidentally broken off 2 pieces. I rooted them. Both of them are growing into ‘normal’ uncrested plants.
    I also have a crested Graptoveria (I think). It came in a dish garden from a Big Box store. I took off 2 leaves and rooted them hoping for more crested plants. Too soon to tell at this point.
    I will absolutely be on the lookout for more crested or Monstrose succulents.

    1. Kat McCarthy

      Hi Lazy K,
      Even rooted crests can start growing non-crested parts. Let the Austrocylindropuntia subulata grow up and keep an eye on them. One may start to crest!
      Fingers crossed for your Graptoveria – they are so cool when they crest!
      Please let me know how they do!

  4. Paul

    Hi Kat:
    How do you get rid of oxalis ? This weed will survive drought long after the cacti die from lack of water.
    The only way I know how to get rid of it is to transplant the cacti that have it. Also, is it possible to graft Schlumbergera (Christmas Cactus) onto opuntia rootstock to make a standard (tree) ? Have you seen one ?

    1. Kat McCarthy

      Hi Paul,
      I’m sorry, I don’t know any better way to clear oxalis from cactus than to take the cactus from the soil, wash the soil from the roots, repot the cactus and bake the discarded soil to kill the remaining oxalis. Using an inorganic top dressing for the cactus does make it easier to keep weeds down, and makes them easier to pull out intact. 🙁
      I will ask some avid cactus-growers in my new Facebook group for succulent and cactus enthusiasts. But we would love to have you join us – you can ask yourself!
      You can definitely graft a Schlumbergera onto an opuntia as rootstock. Though their growth habit and cold-hardiness are wildly different, still, as cactus, they do very well grafted together. I have seen this – and it is so cool! I would love to see the results of yours! To grow to a large size, remember to keep cutting bak new opuntia growth, so the plant sends its energies back to the Schlumbergera. Otherwise, the vigorous rootstock will overgrow the scion.
      Have fun with this – and please share pictures! 🙂

  5. Dan

    Hi Kat. Loved the very info’ve article. I grow a fabulous succulents garden in my small 5th floor urban balcony w about 95 different succs and cacti and also 2 indoor air plants. I have 4 cristatae, one of them the brain cactus. Spanish moss is present also and an orchid too. They all bloom in their own time, though not so much, i think, b/c of lack of adequate light (southward), as they would like to. I water and fertilize them regularly w/o fail. Manually. I love the personal LTC. Every morning i visit them w loving thoughts, singing to them, and even, silly me, kissing them. I have a toothpick handy to remove any foreign object and larvae happening to be on them and every now and then during the day I give them a loooong and loving look thru the living room windows. Best, Dan, Israel.

  6. Erik

    Hi Kat, thank you for the great article. It was very helpful. I have a Montrose, I think, but I’m unable to identity it. If I sent you a picture of it did you think you could help me identify it or at least lead me in the right direction. The person I bought it from had no idea either.

    1. Kat McCarthy

      Hi Erik,
      Thanks so much!
      Sure, send it to me and I will do my best! 🙂 kat [at] thesucculenteclectic [dot] com
      Or, why not join my Facebook group for succulent lovers? We’ll have thousands of people from around the world join in to help you to identify your monstrose!
      Either way!

  7. Beth

    I have one that is the “rollercoaster” looking variety you pictured above. It has been looking great and now so suddenly turning do colour and translucent. It’s there a way to save it at all?

    1. Kat McCarthy

      Hi Beth,
      Yes! It’s possible! First step is to get it out of the soil it’s in, to be sure you stop any damage coming from wet soil.
      The next step may involve “surgery” of a sort. Please snap some photos of your plant and send them to me. I’ll be happy to take a look and let you know what I would do.
      Send the photos to kat [at] thesucculenteclectic [dot] com
      I hope we can save your beautiful crest!

Leave a Reply